Question

The Drexel division of NESCO sells pet food. NESCO's corporate management gives its division managers considerable...

The Drexel division of NESCO sells pet food. NESCOs corporate management gives its division managers considerable operating4.Suppose NESCO competes against DOGCO, a company of similar size in the same business environment. NESCO management is consi

The Drexel division of NESCO sells pet food. NESCO's corporate management gives its division managers considerable operating and investment autonomy in running their divisions NESCO is deciding how it will compensate Tim Thomas, the general manager of the Drexel division. NESCO is considering the following three proposals: » Proposal 1 Pay Thomas a fixed salary o » Proposal 2 Pay Thomas no salary. His compensation would be paid solely on the basis of the division's ROI, calculated as operating income before any bonus payments divided by the division's investment. o Proposal 3 o Pay Thomas some salary and some bonus based on ROI QUESTIONS: Evaluate the three proposals, comparing the advantages and disadvantages of each. Assume Thomas does not like bearing risk. Which of the three proposals will he prefer? Explain your answer in detail. Assume NESCO's goal is to align Thomas's objectives with its own objectives. Which oif the three proposals will NESCO prefer? Explain your answer in detail.
4.Suppose NESCO competes against DOGCO, a company of similar size in the same business environment. NESCO management is considering evaluating Thomas on the basis of Drexel's ROI minus DOGCO's ROI. Thomas complains that this method is unfair because the performance of another company, over which he has no control, is included in his performance evaluation measure. Is Thomas's complaint valid? Explain in detail why or why not. 5. Drexel's salespersons are responsible for selling and providing customer service and support. Sales are easy to measure. Although customer service is important to Drexel in the long run, it has not yet implemented customer service measures. Thomas wants to compensate his sales force only on the basis of sales commissions paid for each unit of product sold. He cites two advantages to the plan: (1) it creates strong incentives for the sales force to work hard, and (2) the company pays salespersons only when the company is earning revenues. Provide at least two reasons that Thomas's proposal is not a good plan. Explain your answer in detail.
0 0
Add a comment Improve this question
Answer #1

1) Proposal 1: It is advantageous for the GM to get a fixed salary as he is assured even in the case of huge losses or low profits. However, the company though has proper knowledge about the amount to be given to the GM as salary can face problems at times of losses as they have to compensate for the salary from some other source.

Proposal 2: This shall not be liked by the manager as it depends upon the operating income and the investments made and the GM has to work harder to get more income which may depend upon many other sources as well. This may not be fruitful for the company as well as the company may face losses if the GM doesn't work well and hence contributes less towards the income.

Proposal 3: This is the best proposal of all as the GM and the company are both in profit by adopting this method. It is because the GM gets a fixed salary and to get more of it he needs to put in much efforts to make income more for the company.

2) In this case the manager will prefer to choose proposal 1 as it will give him fixed income/ salary and it will not bear any risk for the manager in any situation whatsoever.

3) In such a situation, NESCO will prefer proposal 3 as it will be beneficial for both the manager and the company. Proposal 3 gives a fixed amount of salary to the GM and also some bonus based on ROI. Thus the manager is assured of some fixed salary no matter what the situation is and the company is also assured of the managers work contribution as he needs to earn more income.

4) Yes, Thomas's complaint is valid as a company's ROI depends on various factors related to own variables and variables from the surrounding world. However, evaluating his salary on the basis of that of other companies ROI is not valid as it reflects other companies performance which is not on what basis he shall be evaluated. Thus, this method is not fair and shall not be adopted.

5) There are many reasons why Thomas's proposal may not sound good for the company. Two of the reasons are cited below:

a) The sales may be down due to factors other than work load taken by sales force. Reasons for low sale may be substitutes present or the overall market demand going down; thus the sales force would be unable to do anything regarding that.

b) Some of the sales persons may switch to some other company where they are paid fixed income rather than on the basis of number of products sold. This may prove to be fatal for the company.

Thus the proposal provided by Thomas is not a good one.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
The Drexel division of NESCO sells pet food. NESCO's corporate management gives its division managers considerable...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • And there was a buy-sell arrangement which laid out the conditions under which either shareholder could...

    And there was a buy-sell arrangement which laid out the conditions under which either shareholder could buy out the other. Paul knew that this offer would strengthen his financial picture…but did he really want a partner?It was going to be a long night. read the case study above and answer this question what would you do if you were Paul with regards to financing, and why? ntroductloh Paul McTaggart sat at his desk. Behind him, the computer screen flickered with...

  • A. Issues [1] In addition to damages for one year's notice period, can a trial judge...

    A. Issues [1] In addition to damages for one year's notice period, can a trial judge award significant damages for the mere fact of an employee's dismissal, or for the stigma that that dismissal brings? Or for the employer thereafter competing with the ex-employee for the clients, before the ex-employee has got a new job? B. Basic Facts [2] This is an appeal from 2009 ABQB 591 (CanLII), 473 A.R. 254. [3] Usually a judgment recites facts before law. But...

  • Monica’s Designer Handbags: Creative Marketing Decision-Making Based on Financial Analysis—A Case Study Michael T. Manion University...

    Monica’s Designer Handbags: Creative Marketing Decision-Making Based on Financial Analysis—A Case Study Michael T. Manion University of Wisconsin – Parkside Karen Crooker University of Wisconsin – Parkside Peter Knight University of Wisconsin – Parkside Monica learned much about the designer apparel trade as an intern with a major retailer, and started a designer handbag business, selling through independent retailers. She practiced making sound marketing decisions using financial analysis techniques learned in college. These techniques proved useful when a regional discount...

  • Please read the article and answer about questions. You and the Law Business and law are...

    Please read the article and answer about questions. You and the Law Business and law are inseparable. For B-Money, the two predictably merged when he was negotiat- ing a deal for his tracks. At other times, the merger is unpredictable, like when your business faces an unexpected auto accident, product recall, or government regulation change. In either type of situation, when business owners know the law, they can better protect themselves and sometimes even avoid the problems completely. This chapter...

  • SYNOPSIS The product manager for coffee development at Kraft Canada must decide whether to introduce the...

    SYNOPSIS The product manager for coffee development at Kraft Canada must decide whether to introduce the company's new line of single-serve coffee pods or to await results from the product's launch in the United States. Key strategic decisions include choosing the target market to focus on and determining the value proposition to emphasize. Important questions are also raised in regard to how the new product should be branded, the flavors to offer, whether Kraft should use traditional distribution channels or...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT