Question

Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it could affect me economically as US citizen?

Trump Pulls Back From Declaring a National Emergency to Fund a Wall

Trump Says He’s Holding Off on National Emergency Declaration

President Trump said it was up to Congress to break the impasse over a border wall that has led to a government shutdown.Published OnJan. 11, 2019CreditCreditSarah Silbiger/The New York Times

By Annie Karni and Maggie Haberman

  • Jan. 11, 2019

WASHINGTON — President Trump has stepped back from declaring a national emergency to pay for a border wall, under pressure from congressional Republicans, his own lawyers and advisers, who say using it as a way out of the government shutdown does not justify the precedent it would set and the legal questions it could raise.

“If today the national emergency is border security, tomorrow the national emergency might be climate change,” Senator Marco Rubio of Florida, one of the idea’s critics, said this week. Another Republican, Senator Mitt Romney of Utah, told an interviewer that declaring a national emergency should be reserved for “the most extreme circumstances.”

Mr. Trump, who according to aides has grown increasingly frustrated over the refusal of Democrats to bend and sees the shutdown as a road with no off-ramp in sight, hinted on Friday that the warnings were having an effect.

“What we’re not looking to do right now is national emergency,” he told reporters gathered in the Cabinet Room as the shutdown approached its fourth week. Minutes later he contradicted himself, saying that he would declare a state of emergency if he had to.

Advertisement

As Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senator Chuck Schumer, the minority leader, have proved immune to Mr. Trump’s threats, the idea of using the president’s constitutional powers to declare an emergency has received close scrutiny in the White House because it would enable Mr. Trump to obtain the $5.7 billion he has sought for construction of a wall without the approval of Congress.

Instead, Mr. Trump would use his authority to transfer funds to the wall that were appropriated by Congress for other purposes. Toward that end, the Army Corps of Engineers has been directed to study whether it can divert about $13.9 billion in emergency aide set aside for Puerto Rico, Florida, Texas and California. And with the money secured, the president could drop his opposition to the appropriations bills whose passage would end the shutdown.

You have 3 free articles remaining.

Subscribe to The Times

That would allow Mr. Trump to say he had never backed down from his fight with congressional Democrats or abandoned his pledge to build the wall even if the construction became tied up in legal challenges.

Former White House aides, who noted that Mr. Trump did not focus on the wall during the first two years of his presidency, said the optics of fighting for the wall were more important to the president than erecting it.

But opposition has come from many Republican quarters. Some conservatives see it as an unacceptable extension of executive power. Kellyanne Conway, a White House aide, has said it would essentially give Congress a pass. Representative Mike Simpson, Republican of Idaho and a member of the House Appropriations Committee, said it was not clear to him that an emergency declaration would even lead to the prompt reopening of the government.

Advertisement

He called it “a bad escape hatch” that was going to anger many House members.

Mr. Trump’s reluctance is also frustrating allies ginning him up to take action. “If it’s a crisis, treat it like a crisis,” Stephen K. Bannon, the former chief White House strategist, said in an interview. “His best option now is to declare a national security emergency and get on with it.”

On Thursday, Mr. Trump traveled to the border in Texas to dramatize his support for a wall but used a photo-op along the banks of the Rio Grande on Thursday only to repeat his familiar arguments for building it. He sidestepped the issue when Sean Hannity, the Fox News host, asked him in an interview that night to detail what a national emergency would look like.

“There’s some compromise needed,” Mr. Trump said.

But Mr. Trump, who allies said was eager to spend time at his Mar-a-Lago club in Florida and resented the advice of aides to deliver an Oval Office address and travel to Texas on Thursday, is left with few good options.

Asylum seekers in Tijuana, Mexico, outside an entry point into the United States.CreditMark Abramson for The New York Times

DALGO JAL LGO JALISCO MIC RIT NUEVO AIDALGO JALISC INALOA SONORA TABASCO TA PUEBLA OAXAC QUERETA QUERETARO Q QUINTAN QUINTANA AN LUIS N LUIS P RIT NUEVOV SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TAMAULIPAS SIN TAMAULIPAS SINALOA SONORA TAMAULIPAS SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TA SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TA INALOA SON LAXCALA VERACRUZ YUCAIA NUEVALEÓNNA VERACRUZ YUCATAN TLAXCALA LEON NAYARIT N ACAN MOR ACATECAS TLAXCALA VERAC ZACATECAS TLAXCALA VERACRU LAXCALA VERACRUZ YUCATA DRELOS HIDALGO AYARIT NUE MAULIPAS SIN AMAULI MAULIPASs NALOA LOA SON LACATEC ACATECAS T LAXCAL VO LEON NAY CAN VER ATECA CAS TL ALA CALA VE ATEC .ATECAS TL XA TAR ARO QU HIDA AL ALA VERA ERACRUZ YU HID

ImageDALGO JAL LGO JALISCO MIC RIT NUEVO AIDALGO JALISC INALOA SONORA TABASCO TA PUEBLA OAXAC QUERETA QUERETARO Q QUINTAN QUINTANA AN LUIS N LUIS P RIT NUEVOV SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TAMAULIPAS SIN TAMAULIPAS SINALOA SONORA TAMAULIPAS SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TA SINALOA SONORA TABASCO TA INALOA SON LAXCALA VERACRUZ YUCAIA NUEVALEÓNNA VERACRUZ YUCATAN TLAXCALA LEON NAYARIT N ACAN MOR ACATECAS TLAXCALA VERAC ZACATECAS TLAXCALA VERACRU LAXCALA VERACRUZ YUCATA DRELOS HIDALGO AYARIT NUE MAULIPAS SIN AMAULI MAULIPASs NALOA LOA SON LACATEC ACATECAS T LAXCAL VO LEON NAY CAN VER ATECA CAS TL ALA CALA VE ATEC .ATECAS TL XA TAR ARO QU HIDA AL ALA VERA ERACRUZ YU HID

Asylum seekers in Tijuana, Mexico, outside an entry point into the United States.CreditMark Abramson for The New York Times

As he searches for a way to end the political stalemate with Democratic lawmakers, Mr. Trump is finding himself boxed in, in a familiar position when it comes to immigration issues. Former aides say that is because he conflates legal and policy issues with public relations campaigns and does not anticipate an endgame.

In March, Mr. Trump was facing pressure to meet a deadline on a decision about what to do with immigrants who were part of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which allowed young adults brought to the United States illegally as children to avoid deportation and become eligible for a work permit.

Racked by anxiety as he quizzed aides for advice, Mr. Trump turned to an adviser and asked, “How do I get out of this?”

In the end, Mr. Trump was saved, at least temporarily, by a federal appeals court ruling last year that he could not immediately end the program. Mr. Trump moved on.

Advertisement

In the opening weeks of his presidency, Mr. Trump issued an executive order banning citizens from seven majority-Muslim countries from entering the United States. That ban was almost immediately halted in court. A second, rewritten version, however, was upheld by the Supreme Court and was seen as at least a partial victory for the administration.

But Mr. Trump vented, privately and publicly, that the version that passed legal muster was “watered down” and “P.C.,” and made him look “weak.”

How Mr. Trump found himself in his most recent predicament can be traced back to September, when White House aides and conservative lawmakers urged the president to engage in a fight for wall funding. But he was told to postpone the fight until after the election, to avoid forcing vulnerable Republicans in swing districts to take a politically perilous stance on the wall.

When he looked like he might compromise and support a bill that provided far less money for the wall than he asked for, conservatives like Ann Coulter excoriated him, describing him as “gutless,” and he backed down. Soon he was telling Mr. Schumer and Ms. Pelosi during a televised Oval Office meeting last month that he would proudly “own the shutdown,” thrilling conservatives.

Buoyed by the praise, and encouraged by the acting White House chief of staff, Mick Mulvaney, Mr. Trump decided to keep digging in.

But that encouragement for what played well in a viral television moment never led to a coherent strategy for a prolonged stalemate, according to a half-dozen people in the White House or working with the administration on a way to end the shutdown.

Mr. Trump’s allies insist that he is winning the political battle.

“Democrats are boxed in,” said Greg Mueller, a conservative strategist. “Every time the president and G.O.P. go to the Democrats with a fix, they say no, which positions them as obstructionists ignoring the problem, and opening themselves up for major troubles in 2020.”

Advertisement

Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, who had tried and failed to find an alternative to reopen the government earlier in the week, emerged from a meeting with Mr. Trump on Friday declaring that it was clear Democrats “don’t want to make a deal and will never support border wall/barriers.”

And he encouraged the exact action many of his colleagues were warning against. “Mr. President, declare a national emergency now,” he said. “Build a wall now.”

Mr. Trump’s aides said they expected the stalemate over the wall funding to be resolved by the time he delivers the State of the Union address on Jan. 29. But the White House also has drafts based on the shutdown being over — or well into its sixth week.

Correction: January 10, 2019

An earlier version of this article misstated the amount of money in emergency aid the Army Corps of Engineers has been directed to study as a possible source of funding for a border barrier. It is $13.9 billion, not $13.9 million.

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Article focusses on national shutdown in lieu of not getting Border wall cinstructed for the fact that national emergency shutdown is critical and complex and in future can be due to climatic change as well and may lead to potential economic losses and unemployment.

Article suggests that Trump can utikise The constitutional powers and use for construction of The Wall. Instead which could be used to solve issues of Puerto rico erstwhile . Trump which was caught in midst of solvibg problem of immigration and deportation also backed down by Federal judgement . Thus articlebasicallycaptures various political and legal aspects which form paradox and how they have been ruled in the end.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it could...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Hi can You help me make a summary about this short article, and also tell me...

    Hi can You help me make a summary about this short article, and also tell me how it affects me economically as US citizen ? As Government Shutdown Persists, Americans Feel the Bite Members of the Secret Service on Monday outside the White House. Virtually every employee with the agency is required to work during the shutdown.CreditDoug Mills/The New York Times Image Members of the Secret Service on Monday outside the White House. Virtually every employee with the agency is...

  • Hi cam you help me make a summary about this short article, and how it affects...

    Hi cam you help me make a summary about this short article, and how it affects me economically as US citizen? Trump Has Promised to Bring Jobs Back. His Tariffs Threaten to Send Them Away. By Peter S. Goodman Jan. 6, 2019 HOLLAND, Mich. — Plants in every direction shut down and moved their operations to Mexico, succumbing to the relentless pressure to cut costs in an age of globalization. Not EBW Electronics. As the decades passed, the family-owned business...

  • Hi can you help make a summary about this short article and how it affects me...

    Hi can you help make a summary about this short article and how it affects me economically as US citizen ? Federal spending outpaced revenue by $317 billion over the first three months of fiscal 2019, according to the Congressional Budget Office.CreditSarah Silbiger/The New York Times Image Federal spending outpaced revenue by $317 billion over the first three months of fiscal 2019, according to the Congressional Budget Office.CreditCreditSarah Silbiger/The New York Times By Jim Tankersley Jan. 8, 2019 WASHINGTON —...

  • Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects...

    Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects me economically as US citizen ? Supported by Federal Shutdown’s Uneven Toll: Some Americans Are Devastated, Others ObliviousFederal Shutdown’s Uneven Toll: Some Americans Are Devastated, Others Oblivious “It has been terrible,” said Andrea Caviedes, a furloughed loan processor in the Agriculture Department’s rural development program.CreditMichael B. Thomas for The New York Times Image “It has been terrible,” said Andrea Caviedes, a furloughed loan processor...

  • Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects...

    Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects me economically as US ciizen ? US-China Trade Talks Wrap Up After Extending To Third Day Facebook Twitter Flipboard Email January 9, 20196:39 AM ET Matthew S. Schwartz Twitter U.S. and Chinese envoys extended trade talks into a third day Wednesday after President Donald Trump said negotiations aimed at ending a tariff war were "going very well!" Oliver Zhang/AP After extending to an unexpected...

  • can someone please help me with an introduction paragraph and a summary of the whole article....

    can someone please help me with an introduction paragraph and a summary of the whole article. us. Trump Didn't Kill the Global Trade System. He Split It in Two. Allies find relations modestly tweaked despite the president's rhetoric, while relations with China are entering a deep freeze By Greg Ip Dec. 26, 2018 1136 am. ET When Donald Trump entered the White House on a platform of defiant nationalism nearly two years ago, many feared he would dismantle the global...

  • Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and also how it...

    Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and also how it affects me economically as a citizen of Allentown ? Petition: Save Allentown State Hospital PETITION City resident has 1,400 signatures so far. State lawmakers say facility can not be restored. The Allentown State Hospital was closed in 2010 and has cost taxpayers $ 2.2 million annually in maintenance. (MORNING CALL FILE PHOTO) By Kayla Dwyer Of The Morning Call More than 1,400 people have...

  • Hi can you make a summary about this short article, and also tell me how it...

    Hi can you make a summary about this short article, and also tell me how it does affects me economically ? HEALTH CARE 2 hospitals join consortium to trim drug costs CIVIC St. Luke's, Easton owner sign on with company making generic meds By Anthony Salamone Of The Morning Call Seeing no end to rising prescriptions costs and shortages in much-needed drugs, two area hospitals are joining to nationwide consortium that will produce generic medications for member hospitals without worrying...

  • Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects...

    Hi can you help me make a summary about this short article and how it affects me economically as US citizen? U.S. Carbon Emissions Surged in 2018 Even as Coal Plants Closed Passenger planes at the Phoenix airport in July. Greenhouse gas emissions from airplanes and trucking increased sharply in 2018.CreditAngus Mordant/Bloomberg Image Passenger planes at the Phoenix airport in July. Greenhouse gas emissions from airplanes and trucking increased sharply in 2018.CreditCreditAngus Mordant/Bloomberg By Brad Plumer Jan. 8, 2019 479...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT