Question

Company Y is going to upgrade its facility. The company has a choice between two models....

Company Y is going to upgrade its facility.
The company has a choice between two models. Model A, with a first cost of $510 000 and a service life of 6 years, would save $100 000 per year. Model B, with a first cost of $110 000 and an expected service life of 18 years, would save $15 000 per year. If the company’s MARR is 8 percent, which model is the better buy? Consider both payback period and annual worth as criteria. Also, what is the difference in the results from the two comparison methods?

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Page initial cost annual saving life 510,ooo 10,ooo 6 B 110,000 15,000 18 Present worth analyris » PWA = -570,000 + 100000(PA

-570,000 + 100,000 X (7.623)- 510,000+ 100,000 X (-6302)-510,000 + 100,000 XC-G302) 941,660

P00 3 = [[0,000+ 75,000 x P%. 8. 78 е ) = |loooo+ TS, а до XC9. 372) - 2 SO S80

tou Dare Page Pay back period initial investment annual cash inflow 510,000 100,000 Sr. 4 years Better 110,000 15ooo 7.33 yea

The difference between both is ,if we look at payback period method it suggests model A. But PW analysis suggests Model B.

Note- You can refer to coumpound interest factors table for the values of P/A and P/F.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Company Y is going to upgrade its facility. The company has a choice between two models....
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • 5.42 Nighhigh Newsagent wants to replace its cash register and is currently evaluating two models that...

    5.42 Nighhigh Newsagent wants to replace its cash register and is currently evaluating two models that seem reasonable. The information on the two alternatives, CR1000 and CRX, is shown in the table. CRX $1100 $440 S60 CR1000 $680 $245 $35 in year 1, increasing by S10 each year thereafter 4 vears $100 First cost Annual savings Annual maintenance cost Service life Scrap value 6 years $250 (a) If Nighhigh Newsagent's MARR is 10 percent, which type of cash register should...

  • Kiwidale Dairy is considering purchasing a new ice-cream maker. Two models, Smoothie and Creamy, are available...

    Kiwidale Dairy is considering purchasing a new ice-cream maker. Two models, Smoothie and Creamy, are available and their information is given below (all costs and profits are in dollars): Smoothie Creamy First Cost 13,500 35,000 Service Life 14 Years 12 Years Annual Profit 4,350 11,050 Annual Operating Cost 1,200 3,475 Salvage Value 2,000 5,100 Which alternative is better if the MARR for Kiwidale Dairy is 18.3%. Assume that each alternative can be repeated indefinitely {Perform all calculations using 5 significant...

  • 1(a) A new machine is to be bought. MARR is 10%. The following two models are...

    1(a) A new machine is to be bought. MARR is 10%. The following two models are under consideration. Model First cost Economic life Yearly net savings Salvage value MI $100,000 5 years $50,000 $18,000 M2 150,000 5 years 60,000 24,000 Using the present worth and equivalent annual methods, which model should be bought? 1(b) If you discover a third alternative M3, as shown in the table below, which is the best? MARR is 10%. Salvage value Model First cost Economic...

  • Find cost difference between 2 options using net present worth analysis Your company signed a contract...

    Find cost difference between 2 options using net present worth analysis Your company signed a contract to remove soil from government-owned property. This task requires a specific bulldozer to dig and load the material onto a transportation vehicle. There are two models of ripper-bulldozer to consider: Model Alpha costs $200,000, and two units of model alpha would be required to remove the material within 2 years. Operating cost for each unit would run to $40,000/year for 2000 hours of operation....

  • The XYZ Company loaned some money to one of its vendors so the vendor could upgrade...

    The XYZ Company loaned some money to one of its vendors so the vendor could upgrade its supply chain. In return, the vendor has agreed to pay XYZ $59,726 a year, with the first payment occurring at the end of year 6.The vendor will make a total of 12 payments to XYZ (one per year). What is the annual worth of this loan? Use a MARR of 3% to make the calculation. Hint: Count the years carefully. Calculate the annual...

  • The XYZ Company loaned some money to one of its vendors so the vendor could upgrade...

    The XYZ Company loaned some money to one of its vendors so the vendor could upgrade its supply chain. In return, the vendor has agreed to pay XYZ $59107 a year, with the first payment occurring at the end of year 6.The vendor will make a total of 13 payments to XYZ (one per year). What is the annual worth of this loan? Use a MARR of 4% to make the calculation. Hint: Count the years carefully. Calculate the annual...

  • A production manager wants to upgrade the manufacturing system by adding a new machine. He found...

    A production manager wants to upgrade the manufacturing system by adding a new machine. He found that one of two machines can effectively be used; their cost data are given in Table Q3  below:                                          Table Q3 Alternative Machines Cost Element M/C I M/C II First cost Anual Maintenance Operating cost/hr Useful life Salvage value £150,000 £3000 £1.6 6 years £10,000 £250,000 £3500 £1.2 8 years £25,000    Using an interest rate of 15%  per year compounded annually, answer the following: What is the...

  • J.Doe must choose beta en tuo different models. The study period considered is 6 years. Mesel...

    J.Doe must choose beta en tuo different models. The study period considered is 6 years. Mesel 1 has a life of four years with a first cost of $13,500 and maintenance costs of $1,250 per year in years 2, 3, and 4 (no maintenance costs in year 1). The Salvage value for this model can be estimated using the declining - balance depreciation method (d =266 Model 2 has a life of three years with a first cost of $15.000...

  • The following two models of machines are being considered. Each model, if selected, has to operate...

    The following two models of machines are being considered. Each model, if selected, has to operate 2000 hours each year. MARR is 10%. Which of the following statements is true? Project's Cash Flow Model A Model B n - $6,000 3,500 3,500 3,500 -$15,000 10,000 10,000 Select one: a. The unit profit generated by Model A is $0.54/hour. cross out cross out cross out b. The unit profit generated by Model A is $0.45/hour. c. The unit profit generated by...

  • Your company is considering a $500,000 investment, today, in a new production facility. Production would commence...

    Your company is considering a $500,000 investment, today, in a new production facility. Production would commence two years from today and initial revenues would be realized at the end of the first year of production. Revenues are estimated to be $300,000 for the first production year, but are expected to fall $30,000 each year thereafter because of a forecasted decline in demand. Meanwhile, operating expenses are incurred at the beginning of each production year and are estimated to be $80,000...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT