


The following graph shows Sparkle's demand curve, marginal-revenue (MR) curve, average-totalcost (ATC) curve, and marginal-cost (MC) curve.
Use the black point (plus symbol) to indicate Sparkle's profit-maximizing output and price.
The following graph shows Sparkle's demand curve, marginal-revenue (MR) curve, average-totalcost (ATC) curve, marginal-cost (MC) curve, and profit-maximizing output and price.
Suppose the government required Sparkle to produce the efficient level of output.
Which of the following describes what would happen to the firm and Sparkle's customers?
- Sparkle would earn positive profit and increase production, boosting consumer surplus.
- Sparkle would earn negative profit, forcing it to shut down, and Sparkle's customers would gain no consumer surplus.
- Sparkle would earn zero profit, and its customers would be just as well off as before.

if price is reduced, P < ATC, so
Sparkle would earn negative profit, forcing it to shut down, and
Sparkle's customers would gain no consumer surplus.
Sparkle is one firm of many in the market for toothpaste, which is in long-run equilibrium....