Question

"What do you mean, you don't know who he is?" asked Dr. Bridewell, the head of...

"What do you mean, you don't know who he is?" asked Dr. Bridewell, the head of the Oakbrook Hospital Renal Unit. He was unconscious when the police brought him to the ER. We started the IV, stopped his bleeding and patched him up. But he still hasn't recovered consciousness. The police think it was a hit and run driver. Dr. Kathy Mc Dowel spoke in a precise, matter of fact voice. Dr. Bridewell always frightened her, but she was determined not to show it. He didn't have any identification? No. They think somebody came along and robbed him. He was wearing jeans and a sweatshirt, nothing that gives any clue as to his background. Both of his kidneys were hopelessly damaged. But his general physical condition is good, and we think he's a good candidate for a transplant. You know we've got someone declared brain dead. Yes, and we've done an HLA match. We're going to have only one kidney to transplant because the other one is shot. But I've got a candidate, too, so we have to decide which patient get the kidney. Who's the other candidate? A Mrs. Benson. She's a woman in her early sixties who's on the school board. Her husband's a rich lawyer, and both of them move in high social circles. She does a lot of work now with a foundation that helps minority children in school. She also happens to be a good candidate physically for a transplant. So you'll choose her over my patient? Dr. McDowell felt herself getting angry. I didn't say that. How old is this guy? Early or middle thirties. He's in good physical condition. But we don't know anything about him, said Dr. Bridewell. He might just be a drifter passing through town. He's probably not a member of the community this hospital is supposed to serve, the one that pays bills and makes donations. Not that we know of, Dr. Mc Dowell admitted. But we don't know for sure, do we? said Dr. Bridewell. Who gets the kidney? Two people need it. There is only one. Should there be a consideration of the worth of each potential recipient and their contributions to society? Would such considerations be morally correct? How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of: Natural Law theorist

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Natural law ethics suggests that everyone in this world has an inherent right that’s bestowed by nature or God as some people believe and it shouldn’t be violated at any cost. This could be understood by human reasoning which is what we normally call the sixth sense. So, it wouldn’t ethical to differentiate people who are rich, socially placed in high class, racially considered superior or even someone who give donation to the foundation. Thus, the man who they treat as no one should also get the equal treatment on par with anyone else.

Thank you for your question. Please rate if you like the answer.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
"What do you mean, you don't know who he is?" asked Dr. Bridewell, the head of...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • .Dr. Yates is a Family Practitioner who has a thriving suburban practice. As one might expect,...

    .Dr. Yates is a Family Practitioner who has a thriving suburban practice. As one might expect, he has a crowded waiting room. On Tuesday, he usually lunches with a colleague at the hospital and then returns to his office to see patients. These lunches cause him to run late getting back to his office about 1/2 the time. When that happens, his patients must wait a bit longer than normal. But, in any event, he rarely manages to see his...

  • Dr. D is the director of surgery at Union Medical Center. He has long been recognized...

    Dr. D is the director of surgery at Union Medical Center. He has long been recognized for his disruptive behavior and outbursts of anger in the OR. Carol, the VP of nursing, makes an appointment to speak with you (Daniel, the new CEO) about the abusive disposition and mood swings of Dr. D in the OR. “Daniel, Dr. D has a history of name-calling and berating Roberta, the OR manager, in the presence of her staff. He fails to follow...

  • You deliver D.Z.'s dietary tray, and he comments how hungry he is. As you leave the...

    You deliver D.Z.'s dietary tray, and he comments how hungry he is. As you leave the room, he is rapidly consuming the mashed potatoes. When you pick up the tray, you notice that he hasn't touched anything else. When you question him, he states, “I don't understand it. I can be so hungry, but when I start to eat, I have trouble breathing and I have to stop.” One theory for the increased work of breathing is based on carbohydrate...

  • Consider this passage: Alice sent that memo to Bill. He got it; Charlie said he handed...

    Consider this passage: Alice sent that memo to Bill. He got it; Charlie said he handed the memo to Bill. Bill says he didn't know about the rule change. That's a lie, since Doreen said she witnessed Bill reading something right after Charlie left his office; the rule change was announced in that memo. Furthermore, Alice announced the change in policy over the public address system while Bill was in his cubicle and awake, for once. Alice couldn't have done...

  • Dear staff, This is Yu.Zhou. May anybody who is good at the Supervisory Management in Health...

    Dear staff, This is Yu.Zhou. May anybody who is good at the Supervisory Management in Health Care Organizations class help me with homework question below. Thank you, sincerely. THE BULLY Wende Carlson, office manager for the hospital’s ambulatory services division, was secretly happy that her half-day conference had been in the morning and not in the afternoon. Mornings in the office were so frantic and stressful that Wende was more than happy to miss a morning once in a while....

  • Gabriela Rivera is an 80-year-old New Yorker from Puerto Rico, who lives alone in her rent-controlled...

    Gabriela Rivera is an 80-year-old New Yorker from Puerto Rico, who lives alone in her rent-controlled apartment. She has lived in New York for almost 40 years and speaks some English, albeit somewhat hesitantly. Gabriela is a devoted mother, calling her children as often as she can afford and even sending them homemade sweets. She raised her children through their teenage years in the same apartment in which she lives today. She is loath to leave it, although she now...

  • "Mrs. Wilkins," Dr. Blake said, "I want to ask you to participate in what we call...

    "Mrs. Wilkins," Dr. Blake said, "I want to ask you to participate in what we call a Phase 1 trial of a new drug called Novamed. The aim of such a trial, it is my duty to tell you, isn't to treat your disease but to help us determine how toxic Novamed is. What we learn may help us figure out how to help other people." "You mean Novamed won't help me"? Mrs. Wilkins asked. "I can't say that it...

  • Domestic violence is characterized by the complexity of the relationships and actions of the perpetrator who...

    Domestic violence is characterized by the complexity of the relationships and actions of the perpetrator who gradually creates an environment where he/she can perform violence and terrorize his/her victims, while on the other hand it is getting increasingly harder for the victim to find a way out of the abusive relationship. This is Esi's story: “When I first saw him, I thought I met the man of my dreams. He was really charming and wanted to be with me all...

  • 1-Summarize the article briefly in your own words. 2-Explain the main theme of this case and...

    1-Summarize the article briefly in your own words. 2-Explain the main theme of this case and its implications for the future of forensic science. 3-Several genealogy sites (including ancestry.com, 23andme.com, familytreedna.com, findmypast.com) were used in this case -- do you believe that law enforcement should have access to these databases as a standard practice? Why or why n Article How a Jane Doe child case uncovered a serial killer, identified victims and changed the use of DNA forensics Investigators and...

  •    Available Feb 11 at 12am - Mar 8 at 11:59pm 26 days Not for IV...

       Available Feb 11 at 12am - Mar 8 at 11:59pm 26 days Not for IV Use: The Story of an Enteral Tubing Misconnection The Story of Robin and Addison Lowe (United States) LEARNING OBJECTIVES After completing this case study, you will be able to: 1. Explore the scientific feld of human factors and how errors like tubing misconnections can be prevented. 2. Discuss the complexity of having two patients to treat, a mother and her fetus. 3. Describe suitable...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT