Question

The Peer-Review Process 1.) Timing: One of the criticisms of the peer-review process is that new...

The Peer-Review Process

1.) Timing: One of the criticisms of the peer-review process is that new ideas take too long to be published. Discuss ONE PRO and ONE CON of this criticism.


2.) Process: Consider the benefits and the detriments of the peer-review process itself. Discuss ONE BENEFIT and ONE DETRIMENT of using peers to review the research of their colleagues.

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

1. Timing:

Pro: It is important to prevent falsified work from being published and ensures only valid scientific knowledge gets published

Con: It creates a lag in publishing and hence comes in the way of budding researchers who want to get hired for some position.

2. Process:

Pro: peer review process provides valuable feedback to the researcher for revising and improving his/her paper before publishing

Con: The process is lengthy and expensive.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
The Peer-Review Process 1.) Timing: One of the criticisms of the peer-review process is that new...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Review your capital budget, which includes plans for a new laboratory (you can select a lab...

    Review your capital budget, which includes plans for a new laboratory (you can select a lab type more suitable to your organization(Radlab)if you wish) and a substantial expansion of the current lab so that its research capacity is increased by one-third, and Review your facility O&M budget search for opportunities to assist her initiative in a significant way. Recognizing that you might need to make a number of assumptions, complete the following assignment. Document any assumptions if they are necessary....

  • Case 3 You work for Salesforce, a large company specializing in customer management and success. Salesforce is proactive in their annual review process, seeking feedback in a 360 degree model, with s...

    Case 3 You work for Salesforce, a large company specializing in customer management and success. Salesforce is proactive in their annual review process, seeking feedback in a 360 degree model, with supervisors, supervisees, and peers completing evaluations for each member of the department. You are the team lead for a team of 5 members. You are responsible to evaluate your five team members and collect peer evaluative information from your five team members. After reviewing the evaluations and data, you...

  • Chapter 19 Test: Managing Quality and Performance 2. The control process (Connect, Perform) Use your knowledge...

    Chapter 19 Test: Managing Quality and Performance 2. The control process (Connect, Perform) Use your knowledge of the feedback control model to select the correct labels for the following diagram. Feedback Adjust standards Adjust performance 3. Compare performance to standards. If inadequate 4. Take corrective action, If adequate Feedback 4. Do nothing or provide reinforcement Establish strategic goals. Establish standards of performace Measure actual performance. Source: Dan, R. L, March, D. (2015). Understanding management (9th ed., D. 629). Stamford, CT...

  • Can someone give Peer review on my blog text, thanks. Robots are coming, are you ready!...

    Can someone give Peer review on my blog text, thanks. Robots are coming, are you ready! Are you afraid of robotic mass unemployment? this issue has been on the lips of the labor market in recent years. An estimated 7% of existing jobs in Finland can be replaced by automation over the next 20 years, so the proliferation of robots will not lead to mass unemployment. Robots come with productivity gains as current production is achieved with less workload. Over...

  • Please read the following post and critique it and ask one question regarding the following post....

    Please read the following post and critique it and ask one question regarding the following post. Discuss characteristics used to appraise when evaluating qualitative and quantitative designs. Which characteristics are the most important and why? For the 0.5 of you that read my posts on the semi regular (besides the professor administrating and grading these assignments of course), you will notice a common theme: "human beings are inherently bias and the greatest part of the scientific method is the reduction...

  • 1. For this question, you will review a process, identify problem areas ( such as wastes,...

    1. For this question, you will review a process, identify problem areas ( such as wastes, cycle time inefficiencies, etc), and suggest an improved process. the document which describes the process steps in words and also includes a process map as a visual tool for understanding what's going on in each step. You will need to respond to the following three sub-questions: A. Of the 9 process steps in the Process Improvement (Final Q 1) document, which specific steps in...

  • (DBA Level )Tick the right answer (only 1 is correct): 1.         Which of the following...

    (DBA Level )Tick the right answer (only 1 is correct): 1.         Which of the following does NOT apply to quantitative research? It uses the scientific method It gives rise to less reliable data than qualitative research It aims to describe, explain and predict phenomena Its methods are tighter and more rigorous than in qualitative research 2.         What is the correct ordering of the stages involved in planning research? Formulate the hypothesis, carry out the study, design the study,...

  • Scenario: When Donald McKay first joined McKay and Mills Construction Ltd., in the 1930s, he started...

    Scenario: When Donald McKay first joined McKay and Mills Construction Ltd., in the 1930s, he started at the bottom. As his son put it, “not quite digging the holes on a building site, but working as the lowest level of manager.” As Donald better understood how the firm functioned, he was involved in increasing levels of decision-making, until he eventually succeeded his father, Anthony, as the head of the family business. This on the-job, “learning the ropes” educational process is...

  • Congn UlIHISsion 074 Cong'c es that arise in research on research to provide guidance on the...

    Congn UlIHISsion 074 Cong'c es that arise in research on research to provide guidance on the ethical on human subjects. The result of the commission's work is this report, hics and elucidates which lays out a general approach to thinking about research tes the three most relevant moral principles-respect for three beneficence, and justice. chical Principles and Guidelines for Res h Involving Human Subjects partly because both often occur together (as in re- search designed to evaluate a therapy) and...

  • There are two parts to this journal: 1. Create a one- two page contract for those...

    There are two parts to this journal: 1. Create a one- two page contract for those students you are a Peer Educator for explaining THEIR duties as a student and what you as a Peer Educator will do for them. Think of it as a Learning Agreement! You can format any way you like. 2. Briefly explain what a typical Peer Education session for you looks like. Do you use any of the mentions skills? How do you Peer Educate?...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT