MKM International is seeking to purchase a new CNC machine in order to reduce costs. Two alternative machines are in consideration. Machine 1 costs $ 450 comma 000, but yields a 15 percent savings over the current machine used. Machine 2 costs $ 950 comma 000, but yields a 25 percent savings over the current machine used. In order to meet demand, the following forecasted cost information for the current machine is also provided. LOADING... Year Project Cost 1 950 comma 000 2 1 comma 350 comma 000 3 1 comma 450 comma 000 4 1 comma 550 comma 000 5 2 comma 400 comma 000 a. Based on the NPV of the cash flows for these 5 years, which machine should MKM International purchase? Assume a discount rate of 13 percent. Assuming a discount rate of 13 percent, MKM International should purchase ▼ because the NPV of machine 1 is $ nothing and the NPV of machine 2 is $ nothing. (Enter your responses rounded to the nearest whole number.) b. If MKM International lowered its required discount rate to 7 percent, what machine would it purchase? Assuming a discount rate of 7 percent, MKM International should purchase ▼ machine 1 machine 2 because the NPV of machine 1 is $ nothing and the NPV of machine 2 is $ nothing. (Enter your responses rounded to the nearest whole number.)
Answer in MS Excel Sheet with step by step Solution:
| Machine 1 | |||||
| Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 13% | Present Value in USD |
| Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -450000 | 1 | -450000 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | 0.884955752 | -840707.9646 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | 0.783146683 | -1057248.023 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | 0.693050162 | -1004922.735 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | 0.613318728 | -950644.0279 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | 0.542759936 | -1302623.846 |
| Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | 67500 | 0.542759936 | 36636.29568 |
| Net Present Value or NPV = | -5569510.301 (Outflow)= -5569510 | ||||
| Machine 2 | |||||
| Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 13% | Present Value in USD |
| Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -950000 | 1 | -950000 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | 0.884955752 | -840707.9646 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | 0.783146683 | -1057248.023 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | 0.693050162 | -1004922.735 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | 0.613318728 | -950644.0279 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | 0.542759936 | -1302623.846 |
| Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | 237500 | 0.542759936 | 128905.4848 |
| Net Present Value or NPV = | -5977241.112 (Outflow) = -5977241 |
Interpretation: as per above Table and calculation, using discount rate of 13%, we find that NPV for using Machine A is Higher than that of Machine B, Thus, we will select Machine A for this project purpose, NPV Value for Machine A and Machine B written in the MS Excel Sheet,
Formula Presented for Reference:
| 1 | B | C | D | E | F | G |
| 2 | Machine 1 | |||||
| 3 | Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 13% | Present Value in USD |
| 4 | Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -450000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D4 | =E4*F4 |
| 5 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D5 | =E5*F5 |
| 6 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D6 | =E6*F6 |
| 7 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D7 | =E7*F7 |
| 8 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D8 | =E8*F8 |
| 9 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D9 | =E9*F9 |
| 10 | Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | =-0.15*E4 | =1/(1+0.13)^D10 | =E10*F10 |
| 11 | Net Present Value or NPV = | =SUM(G4:G10) | ||||
| 12 | ||||||
| 13 | Machine 2 | |||||
| 14 | Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 13% | Present Value in USD |
| 15 | Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D15 | =E15*F15 |
| 16 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D16 | =E16*F16 |
| 17 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D17 | =E17*F17 |
| 18 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D18 | =E18*F18 |
| 19 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D19 | =E19*F19 |
| 20 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | =1/(1+0.13)^D20 | =E20*F20 |
| 21 | Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | =-0.25*E15 | =1/(1+0.13)^D21 | =E21*F21 |
| 22 | Net Present Value or NPV = | =SUM(G15:G21) |
| Machine 1 | |||||
| Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 7% | Present Value in USD |
| Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -450000 | 1 | -450000 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | 0.934579439 | -887850.4673 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | 0.873438728 | -1179142.283 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | 0.816297877 | -1183631.921 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | 0.762895212 | -1182487.579 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | 0.712986179 | -1711166.831 |
| Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | 67500 | 0.712986179 | 48126.56712 |
| Net Present Value or NPV = | -6546152.514(Outflow) = -6546153 | ||||
| Machine 2 | |||||
| Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 7% | Present Value in USD |
| Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -950000 | 1 | -950000 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | 0.934579439 | -887850.4673 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | 0.873438728 | -1179142.283 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | 0.816297877 | -1183631.921 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | 0.762895212 | -1182487.579 |
| Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | 0.712986179 | -1711166.831 |
| Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | 237500 | 0.712986179 | 169334.2176 |
| Net Present Value or NPV = | -6924944.864(Outflow) = -6924945 |
Interpretation: as per above Table and calculation, using discount rate of 7%, we find that NPV for using Machine A is Higher than that of Machine B, Thus, we will select Machine A for this project purpose, NPV Value for Machine A and Machine B written in the MS Excel Sheet,
Formula Presented for Reference:
| 1 | B | C | D | E | F | G |
| 2 | Machine 1 | |||||
| 3 | Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 7% | Present Value in USD |
| 4 | Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -450000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D4 | =E4*F4 |
| 5 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D5 | =E5*F5 |
| 6 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D6 | =E6*F6 |
| 7 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D7 | =E7*F7 |
| 8 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D8 | =E8*F8 |
| 9 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D9 | =E9*F9 |
| 10 | Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | =-0.15*E4 | =1/(1+0.07)^D10 | =E10*F10 |
| 11 | Net Present Value or NPV = | =SUM(G4:G10) | ||||
| 12 | ||||||
| 13 | Machine 2 | |||||
| 14 | Statement | Type | Year | Amount in USD | Factor for discount rate @ 7% | Present Value in USD |
| 15 | Original Cost | Cash Outflow | 0 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D15 | =E15*F15 |
| 16 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 1 | -950000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D16 | =E16*F16 |
| 17 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 2 | -1350000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D17 | =E17*F17 |
| 18 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 3 | -1450000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D18 | =E18*F18 |
| 19 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 4 | -1550000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D19 | =E19*F19 |
| 20 | Project Cost | Cash Outflow | 5 | -2400000 | =1/(1+0.07)^D20 | =E20*F20 |
| 21 | Saving | Cash Inflow | 5 | =-0.25*E15 | =1/(1+0.07)^D21 | =E21*F21 |
| 22 | Net Present Value or NPV = | =SUM(G15:G21) |
MKM International is seeking to purchase a new CNC machine in order to reduce costs. Two...
MKM International is seeking to purchase a new CNC machine in order to reduce costs. Two alternative machines are in consideration. Machine 1 costs $550,000, but yields a 15 percent savings over the current machine used. Machine 2 costs $850,000, but yields a 25 percent savings over the current machine used. In order to meet demand, the following forecasted cost information for the current machine is also provided. Year 1 2 3 4 Project Cost 1,000,000 1,350,000 1,450,000 1,500,000 2,400,000...
MKM International is seeking to purchase a new CNC machine in order to reduce costs. Two alternative machines are in consideration Machine 1 costs $500,000 but yields a 10 percent savings (net benefit) over the current machine used. Machine 2 costs $900,000 but yields a 20 percent savings (net benefit) over the current machine used. In order to meet demand, the following forecasted cost information for the current machine is also provided. Year 1 2 3 4 5 Projected Cost...
MKM International is seeking to purchase a new CNC machine in order to reduce costs. Two alternative machines are in consideration Machine 1 costs $500,000 but yields a 10 percent savings (net benefit) over the current machine used. Machine 2 costs $900,000 but yields a 20 percent savings (net benefit) over the current machine used. In order to meet demand, the following forecasted cost information for the current machine is also provided. Year 1 2 3 4 5 Projected Cost...
Beryl's Iced Tea currently rents a bottling machine for $ 52 comma 000 per year, including all maintenance expenses. It is considering purchasing a machine instead and is comparing two options: a. Purchase the machine it is currently renting for $ 160 comma 000. This machine will require $ 23 comma 000 per year in ongoing maintenance expenses. b. Purchase a new, more advanced machine for $ 250 comma 000. This machine will require $ 18 comma 000 per year...
Beryl's Iced Tea currently rents a bottling machine for $ 51 000 per year, including all maintenance expenses. It is considering purchasing a machine instead and is comparing two options: a. Purchase the machine it is currently renting for $ 155 000. This machine will require $ 25 000 per year in ongoing maintenance expenses. b. Purchase a new, more advanced machine for $ 260 000. This machine will require $ 18 000 per year in ongoing maintenance expenses and...
HT Tool Company HT Tool Co is considering the purchase of a new CNC milling machine to enhance the quality of its custom fabrication services. This project is not expected to change sales, but should save the firm in labor costs. The annual labor savings is expected to be $74,350 (before tax) but the machine will use more electrical power, which is expect to cost $2,400 each year. The machine costs $145,000. It will require $21,000 in modifications to support...
The NPV for Machine b =??????? (round your response to the nearest whole number and include a minus sign if necessary). Tim Smunt has been asked to evaluate two machines. After some investigation, he determines that they have the costs shown in the following table: Copy to Clipboard + Machine A Machine B Original Cost $ 12 comma 000$12,000 $ 24 comma 000$24,000 Labor per year $ 2 comma 400$2,400 $ 4 comma 800$4,800 Maintenance per year $ 4 comma...
Wendell’s Donut Shoppe is investigating the purchase of a new $48,300 donut-making machine. The new machine would permit the company to reduce the amount of part-time help needed, at a cost savings of $6,800 per year. In addition, the new machine would allow the company to produce one new style of donut, resulting in the sale of 1,700 dozen more donuts each year. The company realizes a contribution margin of $2.00 per dozen donuts sold. The new machine would have...
Beryl's Iced Tea currently rents a bottling machine for $ 55 comma 000$55,000 per year, including all maintenance expenses. It is considering purchasing a machine instead, and is comparing two options: A. Purchase the machine it is currently renting for $ 155 comma 000$155,000. This machine will require $ 21 comma 000$21,000 per year in ongoing maintenance expenses. B. Purchase a new, more advanced machine for $ 260 comma 000$260,000. This machine will require $ 15 comma 000$15,000 per year...
Wendell’s Donut Shoppe is investigating the purchase of a new
$42,800 donut-making machine. The new machine would permit the
company to reduce the amount of part-time help needed, at a cost
savings of $5,700 per year. In addition, the new machine would
allow the company to produce one new style of donut, resulting in
the sale of 2,500 dozen more donuts each year. The company realizes
a contribution margin of $1.50 per dozen donuts sold. The new
machine would have...