Question

After having been denied access to several locker rooms in the course of pursuing her profession, Murphy Blue decides to apply for a job as sports editor for the Moscow-Pullman Times newspaper. Although she has ten years of sports reporting experience for the Washington Post, the Times rejects her and hires Bud Stallins. Bud played high school football, but worked as a gourmet cook until he began working last year as a sports reporter for the Colfax Courier newspaper. The Times has never hired a woman sports editor, although several apparently well-qualified women have applied in the past. The reason the Times gave for rejecting Murphy is that football-playing experience is a required qualification for the job.

Discuss Murphy Blue’s chances of successfully pursuing claims against the Times under the Equal Protection Clause, Title IX, and Title VII.

Answer 1

Equal Protection Clause : The Fourteenth Amendment clearly mentions that any state can't deny opportunities to the any class i.e. be in upper, lower, black, white, male, female, transgender.

TITLE IX : The law clearly says that, No state can prohibit based on the gender of the person. Equality is what comes to play.

TITLE VII : The Civil rights act clearly says that, No state can prohibit based on race, religion, color, sex or national origin.

Considering the Times, Murphy is 100% eligible for the sports editor of the Times magazine. She holds 10 years of experience in the sports field.

The Times is completely against the federal laws and should be fined heavily as per the law.